This is a serious work of history, well researched and written by Thomas W. Gilbert, a Brooklyn-based baseball author. Not only does he blow much of the mythology surrounding baseball's origins out of the water, he also tells a lot about the history of New York City and the manner in which the United States developed socially and economically in the nineteenth century. I already knew that General Abner Doubleday did not invent the game. But I had believed that Englishman Alexander Cartwright (one of many bogus "fathers of baseball") had played a key role in baseball's development, which is not true. Nor is it true that baseball descended from the British games of cricket and rounders. While it has been a nice thing for Cooperstown, New York to host the National Baseball Hall of Fame, the true birthplace of baseball is New York City, with a major assist from Brooklyn. Hoboken, New Jersey, gets in on the action, due to it having contained the Elysian Fields, a popular resort area for mid-19th century New Yorkers where New York-based baseball clubs went to play.
The man pictured above is Henry Chadwick, a transplanted Englishman who wrote about baseball, although he preferred cricket, and was a pioneering baseball statistician. He is among those who have been called "the father of baseball", although he certainly didn't invent the game by any stretch of the imagination. He was quick to question the Doubleday founding myth, although he mistakenly considered baseball to be descended from rounders.
There are many other popularly believed myths about baseball's founding and early years that are shattered in this book. The Knickerbockers of New York were not the first organized club, and the 1869 Cincinnati Red Stockings were not the first to use paid players. Other than the variation on the name, the modern Reds are in no way related to the 1869 team.
Charging admission to baseball games came about as a result of the early contests between clubs from Brooklyn and New York, which created fan interest. James Creighton, a Brooklyn pitcher, became baseball's first major star during the amateur era.
Utilizing a unique delivery, in keeping with the rules at the time, Creighton was highly successful until his untimely death at age 21. Like many of the baseball players of the mid-nineteenth century, he also played cricket.
The so-called "New York game" followed the railroads and mercantile routes to become America's national game, pushing aside cricket and local bat-and-ball variations like "town ball". Philadelphia and Washington were fairly quick to adopt baseball, but Boston and eastern Massachusetts stuck with their local game for several more years.
Where did the Doubleday myth come from, you might ask? It was a product of the Mills Commission that was created by baseball pioneer and sporting goods manufacturer Albert Spalding (pictured above) in 1905 with the goal of determining baseball's origins and proving that it was not derived from rounders, as Henry Chadwick had written in an article. The commission concluded that Doubleday invented the game in Cooperstown, New York in 1839. The commission-ratified myth became the officially-sanctioned story (taking on the mantle of holy writ, which is often similarly nonsensical, and like this myth, is no longer believed by knowledgeable people today). But the important thing is that the myth is a myth, or as author Gilbert terms it, bullshit.
This book exposes lots of myths and bullshit. It is also an excellent read and very informative about baseball and America during the sport's early years.
